frame

A given movie's quality should be judged by artistic/intellectual merit as opposed to money made.

Opening Argument

This would 
- Incentivize the creation of movies of a higher intellectual nature: essentially, higher reviews lead to larger audiences, which in turn lead to a more successful movie in terms of money. Giving higher reviews to more artistic and intellectual movies will make them earn more money. Since the movie industry operates to gain profit, it will incentivize more artistic and intellectual movies. Rating them on money made only limits the incentivization of movies to ones that get large audiences in the first place, namely, ones with good trailers that apply to many people. 
- result in an overall more culturally rich community.
- Enable movies to be compared with other movies in the past on a more fair playing field: one where inflation has no major effect.


Debra AI Prediction

Predicted To Win
Predicted 2nd Place
11%
Margin

Details +


Status: Open Debate


Arguments

  • Nah, it wouldn't work.  Usually the movies with the highest reviews are the most boring movies to hit the screens.  I usually find the best movies have mediocre reviews.
  • @CYDdharta, I actually think it's a self fulfilling prophecy. The higher reviews the higher viewership and money made. Most people view reviews before deciding to see a movie.

  • @CYDdharta, I actually think it's a self fulfilling prophecy. The higher reviews the higher viewership and money made. Most people view reviews before deciding to see a movie.

    No, that statement is demonstrably incorrect.  If you compare the top ten highest rated films from 2017 to the top ten highest grossing films of 2017, the only film that was in both categories was Star Wars:The Last Jedi.  I couldn't  Rotten Tomatoes 10 list for 2016, but I did find their top rated movies for 2016.  If you compare the movies that rated 98% to 100%, 22 in all, to the top ten grossing films of 2016, the only movie that was in both categories was Zootopia.
  • CYDdharta said:
    @CYDdharta, I actually think it's a self fulfilling prophecy. The higher reviews the higher viewership and money made. Most people view reviews before deciding to see a movie.

    No, that statement is demonstrably incorrect.  If you compare the top ten highest rated films from 2017 to the top ten highest grossing films of 2017, the only film that was in both categories was Star Wars:The Last Jedi.  I couldn't  Rotten Tomatoes 10 list for 2016, but I did find their top rated movies for 2016.  If you compare the movies that rated 98% to 100%, 22 in all, to the top ten grossing films of 2016, the only movie that was in both categories was Zootopia.
    This may be true, but keep in mind that reviewers can be completely biased when reviewing a movie. I saw a movie that got a 66%, but I thought was really great, and a film that got a 89% that I thought was mediocre. I think that judging a movie by the intellectual and artistic content would work because it would allow a more diverse style of reviewing a film. It would challenge reviewers to rate the ideas or themes presented by the movie rather than the special effects and plot captivation. However, this is somewhat already addressed when reviewers talk about bland characters or many loopholes in the story line. One of the best things to do is simply, when watching the movie, what areas do you think they did good in, say animation, acting, story line, and what lacked, say plot, themes, decoration? Overall, reviewers can give you a general idea of the film, but the audience is the overall judge. Therefore, it is meaningless to compare higher grossing films to highest rating because money and personal opinions don't need to correlate. Higher grossing films mean that the movie was advertised to the right people or that it was a recognizable name in a franchise, but higher ranking sets the bar for what you can "possibly" expect the quality to be.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Back To Top

DebateIsland.com | The Best Online Debate Website!

| The Best Online Debate Experience!
2018 DebateIsland.com, All rights reserved. DebateIsland.com | The Best Online Debate Experience! Debate topics you care about in a friendly and fun way. Come try us out now. We are totally free!

Contact us

customerservice@debateisland.com
Awesome Debates
BestDealWins.com
Terms of Service

Get In Touch