frame
Howdy Debater!
Sign In Register


          
+ NEW DEBATE

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Do you support affirmative action?

Is affirmative action fair, and supports the right economic benefit?
  1. Do you support affirmative action16 votes
    1. Yes
      69%
    2. No
      31%
Comments
  • inc4tinc4t 49 Points
    That is a difficult question, as I support helping those at disadvantage because of their race. That said, we now leave in a global complex economy, and affirmative action should be updated to reflect the realities of 21st century.
  • ale5ale5 34 Points
    I dont agree with inc4t on this point. Affirmative action gives a chance to those who never would have chance otherwise to get out of generations of life in projects. We should continue to support it.
  • I am not supportive of policy that protects one race, while hard working asians with all a grades cannot get to top schools because their race is not considered preferred on college applications
  • I suporta affirmative action.
  • I support it as well.
  • 60% support it based on the poll so far. I continue to support it, although I think some updates should be considered to reflect the reality of our times
  • Yes, I do support that.
  • VaulkVaulk 14 Points
    ale5 said:
    I dont agree with inc4t on this point. Affirmative action gives a chance to those who never would have chance otherwise to get out of generations of life in projects. We should continue to support it.
    @ale5 I'm in support of your viewpoint here.  I'm afraid any organization that is the cause of what you're talking about is not a just organization.  After SAT examinations, U.S. Citizens of Asian ethnicity, who scored nearly perfect on their SAT exam, were denied entrance into colleges that other ethnic and racial groups were given access to...who also scored lower on their SAT exam.  ANY organization responsible for this socialist approach CANNOT be good for our country.  The ones who work harder and score higher are punished, meanwhile those who work less and score lower are awarded...sounds pretty wrong to me no matter what the circumstances.
  • joecavalryjoecavalry 37 Points
    Yes, affirmative action is great. I also agree with @Vaulk on this matter.

    the importance is very high as well.

    for many students etc. this assist them in the later economy and much more.
  • I disagree with Affirmative action and for a couple of reasons...
    1)it needs to be restructured based on the 21st century as @inc4t had said.
    2) it may not be very helpful for all races etc.
  • agsragsr 143 Points
    I support affirmative action.  It may need to be tweaked though. My concern about stopping support for affirmative action is that poor areas will struggle to break the vicious circle of poverty and lack of education opportunities.
    that said, i can see how unfair it is to Asian kids and others with perfect SAT score.  In general I support meritocracy, but I think this case maybe an okay exception.
  • melanielustmelanielust 22 Points
    Affirmative action is fundamentally unfair. I understand there are communities of disadvantaged people who deserve just as many opportunities as advantaged people, but the policy of affirmative action assumes many incorrect things. 1) People of different ethnicities are automatically disadvantaged or financially unstable - a somewhat racist generalization. 2) Those who are not minorities are automatically advantaged - another somewhat racist generalization. The only way to establish EQUAL opportunity for everyone is to create a level playing field, and that equality ceases to exist when one race or ethnicity is given priority over the other. Schools shouldn't even consider things like race - only academic abilities and the educational/financial environment in which the student lived.
  • hucj_rockhucj_rock 2 Points
    I highly disapprove of affirmative actions. I understand that some are benefiting from this, but not than much. I'm not sure if there is that much of a point.
  • VaulkVaulk 14 Points
    I'm sure that Affirmative Action has made some sort of positive contribution to our Society...I just don't know what it is because their overwhelmingly defining attribute seems to be that of making minorities out to be victims.  I just don't see any organization that teaches ANYONE that they're automatically a victim if they fall into a specific race or ethnic category, as a good thing. 
Sign In or Register to comment.

Back To Top

Debate Anything on DebateIsland.com

| The Best Online Debate Experience!
2017 DebateIsland.com, All rights reserved. DebateIsland.com | The Best Online Debate Experience! Debate topics you care about. We are totally free!

Contact us

customerservice@debateisland.com
Awesome Debates

Get In Touch